Meat Church’s Rubs-First Use

06/18/2023 – Jeff gave me a Meat Church 4-pack of rubs for Father’s Day and we tried two of them today on ribs and chicken smoked on the Recteq at 250°. The meat turned out good although the ribs had a tough bark likely due to being in the smoker too long and too hot. It was in there maybe 4 hours.

Meat Church Pork Butt totry

From Meat Church here.

Ingredients

  • 1 bone in pork butt. 8-10 lbs.
  • Meat Church The Gospel (sub Texas Sugar, Honey Hog Holy Gospel, Honey Bacon or Deez Nuts)
  • Meat Church Honey Hog Hot Rub
  • 1 stick of European or Irish unsalted butter
  • 1 C brown sugar
  • 1 C Apple juice or cider vinegar for spritzing
  • 1 C Meat Mitch NAKED sauce (sub your fav BBQ sauce)
  • 1 half steam pan & foil to cover
  • Optional

Prepare your Smoker
Prepare your smoker at a temperature of 275 degrees. I recommend medium smoke wood for this cook such as hickory or pecan.

Pork butt prep
Remove all excess fat from the pork butt. Only leave minimal on the bottom, although this is less important as you can remove it after the cook. Optional – butcher the area around the money muscle to expose it. You only want to leave it connected by an inch or so for easy removal near the end of the cooking process.

Optional Injection
Mix Meat Church Hog Injection with a high quality juice (e.g., Martinelli’s apple juice, Welch’s White Peach Grape). Inject in a 1” x 1” grid pattern until the pork butt is nice and plump. 

Season the pork butt
Slater the pork butt in yellow mustard to act as a binder for the seasoning. This will not affect the flavor. Rather, it allows the seasoning to adhere more quickly.

whataburger mustard slather

Season all sides of the pork liberally with Honey Hog (The Gospel, Holy Gospel, Deez Nuts or other rubs work as well). Allow the pork butt to “sweat out” which just means let the season fully adhere.

Pork Butt

Smoking the pork butt
This cook should take around 8 hours or so depending on weight. Plan on an hour per pound at most. Place the butt directly on the grate, fat side down.

Boston Butt

Spritz every hour with apple juice or cider vinegr. We are targeting a beautiful mahogany color. This will occur just before the butt starts to turn really dark. This should be around the 6 hour mark with an internal temp near 165.

Boston Butt

At this point remove the butt and place it in a half steam pan. Apply a liberal coating of Honey Hog Hot. Then top with the brown sugar and the pats of butter. sometimes I like to add 1/2 can of a good fruit juice. Jumex juices work great. Using leftover injection or that juice you mixed with is also a good call. 

pork butt

Cover the pan tightly with foil and return to the smoker. If you want to separate the money muscle you will want to do that when it is between 190 – 195 degrees internal temperature.

Continue smoking the butt until it reaches 205 degrees internal temperature.

Pork Butt
Pork Shoulder

Finishing
Simply allow this butt to rest for 30 – 45 mins. Then shred or pull the butt, continually tossing in its own au jus. In the video at the top of this recipes we show you how to use a fat separator for this step.

I typically add a little more seasoning of choice after the shred for added flavor. Enjoy!

Pulled Pork

Country-Style Pork “Ribs” Tweaked Again

6/11/2023 – Bought a tray of “ribs” at Rouses (on sale of course) yesterday. Salted to dry brine and shook on a moderate amount of 6POGS on opposite sides then rubbed them to get some on the other two sides. Put them back on the styrofoam tray, wrapped in clear food wrap, and into the refrigerator overnight. This cook is building on the ideas and lessons learned in our earlier post here.

  • 1:30 PM – Pull them after about a 24-hour dry-brine to “get the chill off”. Started preheating the Recteq to 225° with Master Blend Pellets.
  • 2 PM – Put them on the smoker
    • 3:30 PM – IT was 160°.
  • 4 PM – Basted them with 1.5 cups of ACV and 1.5 cups of So Good BBQ sauce with a tablespoon of 6POGS.
  • Pulled at 3 hrs
  • Wrapped in foil after basting in ACV/SoGood at ½ cup each plus 1 tbsp of 6POGS painted on then poured over them before wrapping them snuggly.
  • Continued the cook in the convection oven at 250° until 6:30 PM.

BBQ Chicken on the Recteq #2

6/3/2023 – This Q is like the one last week but with the suggestions cited in that post; i.e. a more spicy rub and slower initial smoke. The 6POGS and additional smoke time made a really good Q.

  1. 12:00 AM – Trimmed thighs of fat and excess skin. Salted one side to dry brine and put back into the refrigerator.
  2. 3:00 AM – Seasoned moderately with 6POGS Rub under the skin and on top as well as the backside.
  3. 4:30 PM – Preheat Recteq to 300°F and allow to come up to temp.
  4. 5:00 PM – Placed chicken on Recteq and smoked for about 70 minutes for the internal temp to be 155 in the legs and 189 in the thigh.
  5. 5:50 PM? – Painted on So-Good BBQ sauce.
  6. Cooked another 15-20 minutes until it reached an internal temp of 190°F in the largest leg.
  7. Removed chicken from Recteq and allow it to rest.

BBQ Chicken on the Recteq

5/26/2023 – This turned out good and it was also easy. The process below was inspired by the instructions at Recteq here.

  1. 8:00 AM – Trimmed thighs of fat and excess skin. Salted both sides to dry brine and put back into the refrigerator. They were a bit salty so next time only salt one side.
  2. 12:30 AM – Seasoned with Cajun Poultry Rub on under the skin and on top as well as the backside.
  3. 4:30 PM – Preheat Recteq to 350°F and allow to come up to temp.
  4. 5:00 PM – Place chicken on Recteq and cook for about 30 minutes. When the internal temp of the chicken is 165°F, paint on So-Good BBQ sauce.
  5. Cook another 15-20 minutes until it reaches an internal temp of 195°F.
  6. Remove chicken from recteq and allow it to rest for 10-15 minutes before serving.

Next time:

  • season it with 6POGS or add some cayenne with the Cajun Poultry Seasoning.
  • preheat to 300 to allow more time for the smoke to connect.

Shrimp Boil Development

6/7/2023 – This test used the leftover seasoning from 5/2/2023 but measured everything. It had the old-time smell of shrimp being boiled but the salt seemed a bit low and the seasoning was not distinctive. The seasoning-to-water ratio seemed ok as after the pre-boil the water had a good color. Next time: boil smaller shrimp for more surface area; increase cayenne pepper and cloves; let them soak longer.

  • 1.5 lbs. headless large shrimp that had been individually frozen
  • 2 Qts water
  • ½ Cup of the 5/2/2023 seasoning mix
  • 2 Tbsp table salt
  1. Boiled then simmered water with salt and seasoning for an hour
  2. Added the large headless shrimp.
  3. Once half was floating took the pot off the burner and added a quart of ice cubes to stop the cooking. Maybe that was too many floating; i.e. boiled too long, as they were a bit chewy rather than crunchy. Could also add more ice.
  4. Let them soak in the seasoned water for 15 minutes.

5/2/2023 – Adjusted the 1/7/2018 recipe below and found it weak likely due to too little added to the water. Boiled one pound of headless shrimp in about 2 quarts with salt and 3 heaping tablespoons of this blend. Next time try at least half a cup in that much water.

INGREDIENTS
4 tablespoons mustard seeds
3 tablespoons coriander seeds
2 tablespoons whole allspice – Ground roughly in a blade grinder
2 tablespoons dill seeds
1 teaspoon whole cloves
1 tablespoon crushed red pepper flakes
1 tsp ground cayenne pepper – Next time 1 Tablespoon
8 bay leaves
2 small lemons were cut in half, the juice was squeezed into the water then they were dropped in.

Added salt and seasoning to the water, brought it to a boil then let it simmer for 30 minutes. Brought it back to boiling and added the shrimp. When some were floating turned the stove off and added ice. Let the shrimp sit in the lukewarm seasoned water to absorb more seasoning as is done with crawfish.

Needed more salt and a lot more seasoning.


1/7/2018 – This boil was based on a Zatarian’s Copy Cat Recipe to which I add cayenne and coarse fresh ground black pepper. It was ok but still not as robust as I remember but well balanced. Need to increase the amount of boil mix.

INGREDIENTS
4 tablespoons mustard seeds
3 tablespoons coriander seeds
2 tablespoons whole allspice
2 tablespoons dill seeds
1 teaspoon whole cloves
1 tablespoon crushed red pepper flakes
8 bay leaves – Torn into small pieces

ADD:
Salt – poured in some, stirred and tasted until the water tasted a little salty. Not nearly as salty as sea water. [Needed more salt]
2 T Cayenne
1T Course ground black pepper
1 lemon quartered and squeezed

Mixed and crushed the large seeds in our new little mortar and pestle where the pestle fully fills the mortar.

  1. Brought ~1.5 gallons of water to a boil with about half of the seasoning mix. Had 3 small red potatoes so threw them in for the first boil. They were done before the 1.5 hours was over and I had pulled them to toss back in later during the cool down.
  2. Simmered for 1.5 hours then returned it to a rolling boil
  3. Added the 2 lbs. of headless shrimp.
  4. Stirred occasionally until a few were floating.
  5. Dropped in a 1-gallon zip lock bag filled with ice cubes. They melted within 20 minutes and cooled off the boil nicely.

Maybe 15 minutes later we shelled and tried some with shrimp cocktail sauce.  The seasoning was evident but still was mild. More salt would have helped and definitely more seasoning.

Many cajun recipes add shrimp boil concentrate and that would have helped.

1/08/2018 – Peeled and had in a “chef” salad. Still very mild seasoning although it seemed well balanced. Tasted the red potatoes and they were bland and no taste of salt.

Briskets & Sausage on the Recteq

4/16/2023 – Smoked a brisket and Connecuh Black Pepper Sausage for our Spring BBQ and Pot Luck lunch to celebrate Frank Knippenberg’s and Digger Creel’s birthdays. The brisket was smoked and then “finished” in the oven but after 10 hours was not fork-tender and a bit dry.

This smoke was done the same as the one last week with the Wagyu brisket Jeff and Maggie brought. That cook—not posted here—followed the advice here and is what was followed for this smoke. The Wagyu brisket was very good and more tender than the one today. It also costs 3X as much.

  1. 4/14/2023, mid-afternoon – Removed heavy surface fat from the Brisket. Salted to dry brine and also added fresh coarse ground black pepper. Put it on a baking sheet and double-wrapped it in plastic sheets. Put it in the outside refrigerator. (We did not dry brine the Wagyu brisket.)
  2. 4/16/2023, 3:30 AM – Removed from the refrigerator and let it sit wrapped on the island to begin warming up.
  3. 4:00 AM – Put the meat into the Recteq preheated to 225°. IT of one probe is 39° and the other is 41°.
  4. 8:00 AM – Probes read 139 and 142 with great color. Pulled, wrapped, and put into the oven set at 225° with the oven probe to stop at 200°. The oven’s probe initially showed the IT as 142° so that is a good correlation with the probes in the smoker.
  5. About noon the IT had only gotten up to 180° so increased the oven setting to 250°.
  6. At 1:00 PM the IT was only 185° so increased the oven setting to 275°.
  7. At 1:30 PM the IT was only ~187° so increased the oven setting to 300°.
  8. At 2:00 PM guests were arriving and we fork-tested it and it was just ok. IT with the handheld in the flat showed it was either side of 200°. Pulled it to rest on the stove. Carved the flat at about 2:30 and served.
  9. Good color with a nice smoke ring but is not fork tender.

Fired the smoker back up at 1 PM and put on the sausage. Pulled it at 2:30 PM when I remembered it was out there. The casing was a bit leathery as it should have been pulled at 2 pm.

Guests:

  • Digger and Carol Creel
  • Peggy and Frank
  • Cathy Downey
  • Frank and Jan Carter
  • Malita Ham
  • Ann Gaston

What would have made it better?

The morning after I began reading Raye Minor’s advice here that I should have read before the smoke. The things I want to do differently next time are:

  1. Wet age the brisket in the original cryovac for 45-60 days as recommended by Raye Minor and also David Somerville here.
  2. Leave ¼-inch of the fat cap.
  3. Time & Temp per Ray – When the bottom brisket [in Ray’s Bradley] hits 168°F internal temperature with the probe inserted in the flat, I monitor the smoker temperature and try to keep it about 225°F which is 250°F to 260°F on my oven setting. I want a slow rise to 190°F or 195°F internal temp in the middle of the flat. At 185°F, test the bottom brisket for fork tender on the end of the flat and continue to test every five degrees. The 195°F internal is as hot as I have ever gotten. Fork tender to me means inserting a long two-tined fork into the end of the flat and twisting. If the meat easily breaks apart, it is fork tender. I repeat on the deckle end but I rely on the flat. With experience, you will be able to judge if a brisket is ready to come out of the smoker by the resistance felt when inserting a temperature probe.
  4. Start the smoke with 12-15 hours allowed plus 2-4 hours resting wrapped in the foil and a towel and placed in a cooler before serving.

Our Russian Dressing

3/17/2023 – Mary made this for Reuben Sandwiches we made with the Pastrami smoked for St. Patrick’s Day here. This prep was inspired by the recipe at Natasha’s Kitchen here but is much spicer. This is not our 1000 Island Dressing that can also be considered Russian Dressing.

  • ¼ cup Blue Plate mayonnaise
  • 1 ½ tsp chili sauce
  • ½ tsp fresh squeezed lemon juice
  • 1 heaping Tbsp creamy horseradish
  • 1 large garlic clove, minced
  • ½ tsp Worcestershire sauce
  • 1 Tbsp onion, finely grated
  • ¼ tsp paprika
  • Salt and pepper, to taste

She bought a bottle of Chili Sauce in the ketchup section of the store. It tasted like a slightly kicked-up ketchup. Next time try regular ketchup with a little cayenne.

After it had melded for a day or so it was much better.

Could also try adding more mayo, the grated onion, and minced garlic to our 1000 Island Dressing which is actually a Russian Dressing. The ratio above computes to 6.67:1 mayo to ketchup (chili sauce) as opposed to our 1000 island dressing which is 3:1.

Pastrami from Store-bought Corn Beef

3/17/2023 – On this St. Patrick’s Day, we seasoned and smoked a 3.5 lb. corned beef brisket flat with a first-time-ever seasoning/rub. The fat was removed from the vac packing and rinsed. This turned out very good and was an easy way to make pastrami for Mary’s favorite sandwich—the homemade Ruben.

The seasoning was:

  • 6POGS not heavy
  • ~3 Tbsp whole coriander that was partially cracked in a cast iron skillet with the meat mallet
  • ~1 Tbsp per side of Brown mustard seed
  • ~1.5 tsp per side of Ground Allspice
  1. Put it cold in the Recteq at 225° loaded with the Recteq Original pellets.
  2. at about hour 4, the surface was drying out so made a baste of EVO and ACV at very roughly 1:5.
  3. at hour 5 it was moist so wrap it in foil—without our usual puddle in the bottom of the foil of ACV—and finished in the oven.
  4. pulled at 155° as they had been in the smoke for 5 hours.

The image shows Mary shaking on the whole brown mustard onto the flat with the partially cracked coriander.

This was the day after Ranger died and at the end of the first week we had Daisy the cat.